Supreme Court Continues Conservative Stance in 2024, No Signs of Change – Analysis by Erwin Chemerinsky
As the dust settles on another eventful year in the U.S. Supreme Court, one thing remains crystal clear: the conservative tilt of the highest court in the land shows no signs of shifting. With three Trump-appointed justices firmly in place, the court’s ideological divide has led to a string of 6-3 decisions favoring conservative outcomes. In his analysis of the court’s activities in 2024, Erwin Chemerinsky sheds light on the key developments that defined the year.
The Rise of the Roberts Court
Chief Justice John Roberts emerged as a central figure in the court’s decisions in 2024, solidifying his position as a key player in shaping the court’s direction. With notable majority opinions and a significant presence in crucial cases like Trump v. United States, Roberts showcased his influence in steering the court’s decisions.
Trump Prevails in Key Cases
Despite speculation about the court’s role post-election, Donald Trump’s clear victory meant that post-election litigation was off the table. However, the court did weigh in on two pivotal cases involving Trump, with the former president emerging victorious in both instances. The decisions in Trump v. Anderson and Trump v. United States underscored the court’s stance on matters related to presidential immunity and constitutional interpretation.
The Administrative State Under Scrutiny
2024 saw significant shifts in the court’s approach to administrative law, with decisions like Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo and Securities and Exchange Commission v. Jarkesy reshaping the boundaries of agency authority. These rulings highlighted a departure from past practices and a move towards increased judicial oversight of administrative actions.
Ethical Concerns and Future Implications
The year also brought ethical concerns to the forefront, with revelations about benefits received by Justice Thomas and allegations surrounding Justice Alito’s displays raising questions about judicial conduct. Looking ahead, the potential retirement of Justices Thomas and Alito could pave the way for a more enduring conservative majority on the court, with long-term implications for future rulings.
Erwin Chemerinsky’s insightful analysis provides a comprehensive overview of the Supreme Court’s activities in 2024, offering valuable insights into the court’s dynamics and the broader implications of its decisions. As the legal landscape continues to evolve, the Supreme Court’s role remains pivotal in shaping the course of the nation’s judicial system.
